Written by Karlo Jennuel R. Antonio, Anna Clarita M. Sangkal and Angeline V. Wilson
From thebarrister’s 42nd Issue
“We are a government of laws, and not of men.”
It is this idea that ended the late dictator Ferdinand E. Marcos’ 30- year reign in Malacañang the reign of absolute power wielded arbitrarily by one man.
During the dark days of Martial Law, the awesome powers of government were concentrated in the infamous despot. He usurped the legislative power through Amendment 6 to the 1973 Constitution, which gave him dominion over the Batasang Pambansa. The Senate Session Hall was padlocked to drive home his point: he was the law in the flesh.
Thus, as soon as the Filipino People banished the tyrant from the country he pillaged, the critical task of restoring our democratic institutions went underway.
The 1986 Constitutional Commission reconfigured our constitution to its present structure in order to purge our political system of the evils spawned by the Marcos tyranny. To insist on this mandate, the framers saw fit to rewrite the preamble yearning for a country “under the rule of law.” Not surprisingly, this phrase cannot be found in the 1973 Constitution of the Marcos regime. In hindsight, we don’t have to guess why.
This aspiration was the very animus why kings and queens were beheaded; regimes and dictatorships were toppled; and revolutions flowed from the springs of liberty. The concentration of power in one person or institution is anathema to the democratic way of living.
Hence, check-and-balance mechanisms have been meticulously embedded in our supreme law.
The Legislature makes the laws. The Executive implements those laws. The Judiciary interprets the laws. Our fundamental law partitioned these powers among the three co-equal branches of government and has demarcated their respective authorities. No branch can intrude upon the power of the other, and all branches must bow down to the majesty of the Constitution.
Even if the President so desperately wants to imprison you for criticizing him, or order the police and the military to arrest you as their commander-in-chief, he cannot. The Bill of Rights is an
interdiction to the whimsical, capricious, and arbitrary exercise of presidential powers. If Congress enacts a patently unreasonable and unjust law, we can call upon the Supreme Court — the last bulwark of our democracy-to strike it down.
What exactly is the rule of law?
According to Retired Supreme Court (SC) Associate Justice Antonio Eduardo B. Nachura, “consistency and compliance with what is just” are the fundamental elements of the rule of law. It means enforcing what has been legislated “in its most just form,” and applying it
Justice Nachura has had the privilege to serve in all three branches of government. He was an undersecretary in the Department of Education during the Ramos administration. He was elected as Member of the House of Representatives for the Second District of Samar. During the Arroyo administration, he was the Solicitor-General of the Republic. Because of his highly decorated and illustrious tours of civic duty, Justice Nachura enjoys a panoramic view of how the rule of law works within and among the Legislative, Executive, and Judicial departments.
For him, the Executive Branch has the most opportunity to violate the rule of law. It is here where the government directly works with the people. Unlike in the Legislature where its members spend most of their time debating in the plenary or in the Judiciary where its functions are discharged inside the courtrooms, the Executive works on the ground. It wields the power of the sword, and the people could instantaneously suffer the impact if that sword is swung unjustly
Thankfully enough, according t o Justice Nachura, the 1987 Constitution has a built-in check against executive abuses. Owing to our experience with the political question doctrine during Martial Law, the present constitution expanded the scope of judicial review. The courts can now invalidate executive acts which could previously aim exemption from judicial scrutiny — if they are tainted with grave abuse of discretion.
But who checks the justices of the SC? It appears the other two branches cannot review the decisions of the highest court.
Impeachment: A double-bladed sword
Justice Nachura reckoned that, under the Constitution, the magistrates of the Supreme Court can only be checked through the process of impeachment. If their decision blatantly desecrates the Constitution, it can generate enough political willpower to impeach them.
The impeachment process is just one of the many times our rule of law proved to be a necessity. Recently, Chief Justice Maria Lourdes Sereno and Commission on Elections Chairman Andres Bautista faced impeachment complaints. Even President Rodrigo Duterte himself had such charges against him earlier this year, but it was dismissed.
“An impeachment proceeding can be considered as the rule of law at work,” according to Justice Nachura. It is an integral part of the check- and-balance mechanism in our Constitution. But it can also be the exact opposite, especially if it is politically charged and the accusations are baseless. Whether the rule of law prevails, the litmus test will be the integrity of the impeachment process. With the game of politics being played by only the powerful few, the ordinary citizens feel helpless and lost whenever the rule of law comes in conflict. Ask the street vendors about the impeachment of Sereno or Corona, chances are they could care less. To them, these issues do not concern them directly. They do not know just how much power the people hold over the entire rule of law and even the Constitution itself
People’s Rule
Ultimately, who enforces the rule of law? We, the people.
“Without the rule of law, we have no means of ensuring meaningful participation by people in formulating and enacting the norms and standards which organize the kinds of societies in which we want to live,” as held by the SC in Lambino vs. COMELEC. And truthfully enough, the rule of law compels the public to display the power of their voice and in return, the public shapes lawmaking itself.
The display of this power was already seen during the People Power Revolution and continues even today. Our opinions matter to the lawmakers and the President listens to our demands and try to appease our sentiments. And when all else fails, the power to amend or revise the constitution still remains reserved in us, the people.
This is the rule of law. We may not be able to legislate or execute the law, but our voices alone already have an impact on the entire system of government. Our outcry shapes the law and our silence determines if it is functioning well. As Justice Nachura puts it, “[you can say that the
rule of law is functioning perfectly, if you do not hear any complaints.”
30 years in
On February 2, 1986, the Filipino people ratified our constitution thirsting for a government “under the rule of law.” Today, we still thirst. In the Millennium Chalenge Corporation’s (MCC) recent scorecard, the Philippines failed to meet the American aid group’s rule of law standard.
The U.S. Congress created the MCC in 2004 as a means of funneling aid to developing countries. As part of its selection process, the MCC determines a recipient-country’s eligibility for aid based on its scorecard, which includes the prevalence of the rule of law as a criterion.
According to the MCC, “[t)his indicator [rule of law standard] measures the extent to which individuals and firms have confidence in and abide by the rules of society; in particular, it measures the functioning and independence of the judiciary, including the police, the protection of property rights, the quality of contract enforcement, as well as the likelihood of crime and violence.”
In this great experiment called ‘democracy, the objective is to create a society governed by a consistent, reasonable, and just set of rules-free from the arbitrariness and caprices of those in power.
In the absence of the rule of law, law enforcers could play god and choose which among us get to live or die. For Justice Nachura, the alleged rampancy of extrajudicial killings is an opportunity for us to reflect on our adherence to the rule of law.
As former U.S. President Dwight D. Eisenhower suggests, the clearest way to show what the rule of law means to us in every day life is to recall what has happened when there was no rule of law. The wounds of dictatorial rule are still fresh to us, but it seems we may be slowly starting to unlearn the lessons of our past. We must take a step back and reflect: are we still a government of laws, or of men?